Skip to Main Content
Back to News

How Five-Year Notes Are Becoming the Safe Haven for Risk-Averse Investors

Quiver Editor

U.S. Treasury (TLT) traders are zeroing in on five-year notes as tariffs cast a shadow over the Federal Reserve’s policy outlook and reignite worries about economic growth. The higher-than-usual demand for derivatives tied to five-year maturities underscores Wall Street’s belief that this segment is better insulated from both immediate policy shifts and longer-term deficit concerns.

While two-year notes typically react sharply to Fed signals, and 10- or 30-year bonds bear the brunt of deficit and economic anxieties, the “belly” of the curve at five years has emerged as a sweet spot. Several major banks, including Goldman Sachs (GS), Barclays (BCS), Morgan Stanley (MS), and Wells Fargo (WFC), have advocated five-year Treasuries since the Fed’s last meeting. Options market flows also reveal investors positioning for a possible yield decline to around 3.55% in April.

Market Overview:
  • Tariffs and inflation fears are pushing policy-sensitive yields higher in the short term.
  • Long-dated bonds face mounting concerns over deficits and economic health.
  • Major investment houses favor five-year Treasuries for a balance of resilience and yield.
Key Points:
  • Policy-sensitive two-year yields have risen to about 4% as traders price in two 2025 rate cuts.
  • Ten-year yields are climbing amid weak consumer confidence and looming data releases.
  • Five-year options flows indicate bets on yields dropping toward 3.55% by late April.
Looking Ahead:
  • Traders await the April 2 tariff decision that may influence inflation and Fed policy.
  • Upcoming job data and CBO deficit warnings could sway yield-curve positioning.
  • Focus remains on the five-year sector’s capacity to buffer macroeconomic volatility.
Bull Case:
  • The five-year Treasury segment offers a balance of yield and relative stability, making it an attractive investment option for those seeking to navigate policy uncertainty and macroeconomic volatility.
  • Major banks' advocacy for five-year Treasuries suggests a consensus among financial experts that this maturity provides a safer haven compared to more policy-sensitive two-year notes or longer-term bonds exposed to deficit concerns.
  • Options market flows indicating bets on yield declines suggest that investors are positioning for potential rate cuts or easing economic conditions, which could further boost demand for five-year Treasuries.
  • The focus on five-year notes may provide a buffer against immediate policy shifts, allowing investors to maintain exposure to fixed income while minimizing risks associated with short-term Fed actions or long-term economic trends.
  • A successful positioning in five-year Treasuries could offer investors a strategic advantage in managing their portfolios during periods of heightened uncertainty.
Bear Case:
  • Despite their perceived stability, five-year Treasuries are not immune to broader economic trends and could still be impacted by significant changes in inflation expectations or fiscal policy.
  • The reliance on five-year notes as a safe haven may lead to overcrowding in this segment, potentially reducing yields and diminishing returns for investors if too many market participants flock to this maturity.
  • Policy uncertainty, particularly around tariffs and potential rate cuts, could continue to create volatility, making it challenging for investors to accurately predict yield movements even in the five-year sector.
  • Investors betting on yield declines may face losses if economic data surprises or policy announcements lead to unexpected rate hikes or yield increases.
  • Long-term economic concerns, such as rising deficits and inflation risks, could eventually impact the entire yield curve, including five-year Treasuries, if not adequately addressed by policymakers.

Investors will watch closely as President Donald Trump’s tariff moves and economic releases converge, creating potential headwinds for growth and raising inflationary risks. With five-year notes viewed as a safer middle ground, the appetite for this maturity may intensify if uncertainty around trade policy persists. Meanwhile, bond auctions and market signals will continue to shape expectations for rate cuts later this year.

Looking beyond the near-term volatility, the resilience of five-year Treasuries highlights their growing appeal in a murky macro environment. Strategists say the next few weeks could prove pivotal for reaffirming the so-called “belly” trade as investors weigh the balance between Fed caution and fiscal pressures.

About the Author

David Love is an editor at Quiver Quantitative, with a focus on global markets and breaking news. Prior to joining Quiver, David was the CEO of Winter Haven Capital.

Add Quiver Quantitative to your Google News feed.Google News Logo

Suggested Articles